Lily King

You knew I’d write a book about you someday.

Our narrator (nicknamed Jordan, real name never given) is a professional novelist in her late 40s who understands good love stories—their secrets and subtext, their highs and free falls. But her greatest love story, the one she lived, never followed the simple rules. The novel is both prequel and sequel to King’s 2020 novel Writers & Lovers (features same protagonist years apart). Heart the Lover is divided into parts mirroring the course of love story: college years, then decades later. Fall of her senior year of college, she meets two star students from her 17th-Century Lit class: Sam and Yash. Best friends living off campus in elegant house of professor on sabbatical, the boys invite her into their intoxicating world of academic fervor, rapid-fire banter and raucous card games. They nickname her Jordan (referencing The Great Gatsby—she’s their Daisy, their Jordan, caught between them). She quickly discovers the pleasures of friendship, love and her own intellectual ambition. But youthful passion is unpredictable, and soon she finds herself at the center of a charged and intricate triangle. She must choose. She chooses Sam.

They marry young. Years pass. Then present day: Jordan is established novelist, Sam is her husband, and Yash has been out of their lives for decades. But crisis brings all three together again—someone is dying, or dead, or in trouble (King keeps this ambiguous initially). The reunion forces Jordan to reckon with the road not taken, the love she didn’t choose, the life she might have had. Through alternating timelines, we see: the heady campus romance, the choice made, the consequences lived with, and finally the reckoning decades later. Did she choose right? What did she lose? What did she gain? Can you love two people? Is there one “right” choice?

The Plot/Key Appeal: Lily King at her very best. Intimate, overwhelming novel about desire, friendship, loss, and the lasting impact of first love. The triangular structure echoes Euphoria (King’s breakout novel) but this is more intimate, less epic. King’s prose is witty, insightful, emotionally acute—Jordan’s first-person narration is observant and distinctive. The college sections capture intellectual intensity, sexual awakening, being young and brilliant and not knowing anything yet. The present-day sections are suffused with longing, what-ifs, the weight of decades of choices. Connections to Writers & Lovers enhance both books (Casey the protagonist in that book makes appearance; Jordan is her).References to other literary love triangles abound (Gatsby, Jules et Jim). Some readers will cry—emotional gut-punch. Character work is extraordinary. All three leads are flawed, real, complicated. Chicago Tribune: “sincere.” Boston Globe: similar sentiment. NYT: “nostalgia distilled in black ink.” Final chapter gives shivers.

Why It’s Trending:

• Released October 7, 2025.


• Instant NYT Bestseller.


• Longlisted for National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction.


• Longlisted for 2026 Joyce Carol Oates Prize.


• BEST BOOK OF 2025: TIME Magazine, NYT, Washington Post, Harper’s Bazaar (10 Best), NPR, Vogue, Oprah Daily, People, USA TODAY, Literary Hub, Kirkus, BookPage, Apple, Spotify, Amazon, B&N, PEN America, Chicago Public Library.


• 2026 PEN/Faulkner Award Longlist.


• Emma Straub: “Lily King has written another masterpiece. This book overflows with her brilliance and her heart.”


• Zadie Smith picked it for Elle.com Shelf Life as “book that made me weep uncontrollably.”

For fans of: campus novels, love triangles, literary fiction, Sally Rooney (Normal People), books about books/writers, coming-of-age, emotional gut-punches, beautiful prose.

Book clubs will have rich discussions: who should she have chosen? Is there “one true love”? How do choices shape us? Regret and acceptance. First love’s lasting impact. Book references and literary analysis. Warning: emotional—tissues necessary. Slow-paced literary fiction, not plot-driven thriller.