Isola

Isola by Allegra Goodman is a sweeping work of literary historical fiction that was a Reese’s Book Club Pick in February 2025. While it was released a year ago, it is currently seeing a “second life” in buzz as the paperback version hit shelves in late 2025, making it a popular choice for book clubs right now.

The Plot
Set in the 16th century and inspired by the true story of French noblewoman Marguerite de la Rocque, the novel follows a young orphan whose life is upended by her cruel guardian and cousin, Jean-François de Roberval.

After squandering Marguerite’s massive inheritance on a colonial expedition to “New France” (modern-day Canada), Roberval forces her to join the voyage. During the journey, Marguerite falls in love with Roberval’s secretary, Auguste. When their forbidden affair is discovered, the enraged guardian abandons Marguerite, her lover, and her devoted nurse, Damienne, on a desolate, rocky island in the Gulf of Saint Lawrence.

The story then shifts into a harrowing, beautifully written survival epic. Marguerite, once a woman of silk and pearls, must learn to hunt, build shelter, and endure the brutal Canadian winter.

Key Tropes & Themes

• Survival & Resilience: It’s often described as a “feminist Robinson Crusoe.” The heart of the book is Marguerite’s transformation from a sheltered girl into a resourceful survivor.
• Found Family & Loyalty: The bond between Marguerite and her nurse, Damienne, is the emotional anchor of the book.
• The “Cruel Guardian” Trope: The antagonist, Roberval, represents the stifling patriarchal power of the era.
• Faith vs. Nature: Marguerite grapples with her religious upbringing as she faces the raw, indifferent power of the natural world.

Why it’s Trending on BookTok

• The “Reese Effect”: Because it was a Reese Witherspoon pick, it has a permanent spot on “aesthetic” bookshelves and in “Monthly Wrap-Up” videos.
• Historical Accuracy: BookTok creators who love “meticulous research” (like fans of The Frozen River or Matrix) have been championing this for its atmospheric detail.
• Emotional “Gut-Punch”: Without giving too much away, there are several tragic moments involving loss and isolation that have led to “reaction” videos of readers crying.
• Dark Academia Adjacent: Though it’s a survival story, the early chapters set in a French château and the lyrical, “prestige” prose style appeal to the Dark Academia and Literary Fiction communities.